mercredi, décembre 14, 2005 1) Maybe Dumbledore was originally a Death Eater, and his hand shrivelled up because he was trying to burn the Dark Mark off. And Snape's really a loyal Death Eater (as he said to Bellatrix at the beginning of HBP), and he killed Dumbledore in a final fit of pique.2) I wonder if Daniel Radcliffe will turn out to be the Mark Hamill of this age? (i.e. no more jobs.) I thought it would perhaps be Elijah Wood (there comes the comparison again), but I think Wood has had critical success before LotR, and as Kevin, of course. 3) But there has to be at least ONE Death Eater who has "left... (Voldemort's) service forever" (see GoF when he first talks to the Death Eaters once he 恢复健康-ed) - if not Snape, then who? (Dumbledore! See Point 1) But perhaps it could be Karkaroff, who was found dead "in a shack up north" (HBP.) In which case, Snape is bad. 4) JKR will NEVER need to work again. Neither will her children, I think. 5) Voldemort's good at Legilimency (mind rape), Snape's good at Occlumency (mind block), so what does this mean?  6) When Narcissa first went to Snape with her plea to protect her son, Snape said that he had known of Voldemort's plans, but he never said anything incriminating - in fact, it could be said that he used an excellent interrogation technique to draw the information out of her. Rather unfortunately, he had to make that stupid Unbreakable Vow, so he had to kill Dumbledore for Malfoy Jr.Rather unfortunately, JKR's choice of words at the end, when DD dies, she puts "revulsion and hatred" on Snape's face. I want to believe... that Snape is good. 7) Occam's Razor limits creativity. :) (In case you haven't guessed, I'm on a Harry Potter kick right now...) ETA 8) After reviewing HBP, Snape looks unredeemable. (Or IRredeemable, depending on how your kilt flies in the wind. Thanks to Ms Ee for the correction... I think. You can TOO draft!) Libellés : harry potter [Potter Putter] |
0 Comments: |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
